Chabad History: 📜 The Mystery of the Kherson Archive: Real Letters of Baal Shem Tov or Not?
Community
Imagine a real historical detective who has been worried about the Jewish world for more than a hundred years. In the midst of revolutionary chaos, the archives of the tsarist police fell into the hands of the Hasidim. And these were not ordinary official reports, but ancient manuscripts signed by the founder of Hasidism — Baal Shem Tov — and his famous students.Fierce controversy immediately erupted around this find. Some kissed the manuscripts with tears of joy and considered them an invaluable shrine, while others insisted that it was only a masterful fake. The discussion continues to this day.🕵️♂️ How did you find the archive?Everything happened in 1918, during the civil war on the territory of the former Russian Empire. The laws actually did not work, and the old government was rapidly collapsing.In Kherson, the crowd destroyed the building of the local Cheka, which inherited the archives of the former tsarist secret police. Secret documents were simply thrown out on the street. Local merchants, sorting through the papers, unexpectedly came across old Jewish letters with the signatures of prominent Hasidic righteous people.The documents were transported to Odessa and began to be sold simply in the markets. At first, many considered them to be fake, but the papers had official state stamps. Subsequently, it turned out that the police seized this archive many years ago during a search of the famous Ruzhinsky Rebbe — Rabbi Israel from Ruzhin.When the Hasidim realized what a jewel was in front of them, the wealthy Hasid Shmuel Gurariy bought the archive and presented it to the Fifth Lubavitcher Rebbe — Rabbi Rashab.Along with the documents, personal belongings of Baal Shem Tov were preserved: a silver snuff box in the shape of a fish, a silver turret and his personal seal.📝 Originals or copies?TheFifth Lubavitcher Rebbe, and later the Sixth and Seventh Rebbe, studied these documents extremely carefully — line by line.They said frankly:“These are not originals, these letters are not written by the hand of Baal Shem Tov himself.”In the 18th century, there were neither printing presses nor modern methods of fast copying. Having received a letter from their teacher, the Hasidim sought to share it with friends in other cities, so they manually rewrote it. Errors such as missing words, incorrect letters, or inaccurate dates may have occurred during such rewriting.At the same time, the leaders of Chabad stressed: despite the mistakes of the scribes, the spiritual content and the main idea of these letters remain reliable.⚡ Why was there a dispute?Not everyone accepted this conclusion. Many prominent rabbis and historians have stated that the entire archive is a forgery.The main arguments of the critics were as follows:all about 300 letters were allegedly written by about 30 different people, but the style of presentation is very similar, as if they were created by one author;the texts revealed historical inaccuracies regarding the dates and names of cities;authors often signed their mothers' names (e.g., “Israel, son of Sarah”). This method is traditionally used in requests for blessing or healing, but it looks unusual for ordinary correspondence.🛡️ How did the Lubavitcher Rebbe protect the archive?The Seventh Lubavitcher Rebbe strongly defended the archive and responded to these remarks.He explained that mistakes can be one of the strongest proofs of authenticity. If one were to deliberately create a fake for profit, one would scrutinize every historical detail. Such inaccuracies naturally arise when people quickly rewrite the text for their own use.In addition, the Rebbe noted that at that time there was hardly a person in the south of Ukraine capable of independently creating about three hundred complex cabalistic texts.The similarity of style also has a natural explanation: the students of Baal Shem Tov imitated the manner of presentation of their teacher. In addition, the letters contain information and details that were known only in the circle of Hasidic Rebbe families.🏛️ Where is the archive today?In the 1930s, some of the letters were published in a Hasidic magazine"A-Tomim"c74(97A29.4'During World War II, the Sixth Lubavitcher Rebbe managed to remove this archive from the Soviet Union.Today, the archive and personal belongings of Baal Shem Tov are stored in New York, in Brooklyn, in the library of the Lubavitcher Rebbe.📸Client Name:baal-Shem-Tov's letter from the Kherson archive.📖Source:"Lubavitcher Calendar".