📜 The historical struggle for the Schneerson library: how the books ended up in Russia and led to huge fines
Community
The history of the Schneerson Library is one of the most interesting and complex episodes in which world history, cultural heritage, international courts and big politics are intertwined. This is a tale of priceless books that went through ordeals and changes of eras and caused a serious diplomatic conflict between the United States and Russia.📚 The Road to Russia: Evacuation and Preservation of the GatheringThe history of this collection dates back to the founding of the Chabad movement. For generations, the Rebbe movement has carefully collected and replenished a unique collection of rare books that have become an important part of the historical and spiritual heritage.In 1914, with the beginning of the First World War, the town of Lubavitchi — at that time the spiritual center of the movement — found itself in a zone of extremely dangerous hostilities. The Fifth Lubavitch Rebbe was faced with a difficult dilemma: it was impossible to transport thousands of books on dangerous roads, but it was also too risky to leave them in the front line. Therefore, about 12,000 printed volumes were packed and sent to a securely guarded warehouse in Moscow to protect them from the horrors of war. The Rebbe took the rarest manuscripts with him in the evacuation.🛑 soviet nationalization: confiscation of the libraryHowever, the political situation in the country has changed radically. After the revolution, the Soviet regime came to power, which began a massive nationalization of private and public property.The warehouse in Moscow was opened, and the entire Schneerson library was confiscated and transferred for storage to state funds — to the Lenin Library, now the Russian State Library. The next Rebbe tried for decades to negotiate with the authorities to return the collection. However, the Soviet leadership declared the meeting state property, categorically refused to return it to its rightful owners and closed access to it.U.S. ⚖️ Litigation and Million Dollar FinesWhen diplomacy finally came to a standstill, representatives of the Chabad movement appealed to the United States federal court, filing a lawsuit against the Russian government demanding the return of the illegally held collection.The American court ruled in favor of the plaintiffs and ordered russia to return the books. The Russian side ignored this verdict, stating that the American judicial system has no jurisdiction over the state property of the Russian Federation, and demonstratively refused to participate in the meetings.In response to the failure to comply with the court decision, the American court imposed a severe sanction — a fine of $50,000 for each day of delay. Over the years of prolonged litigation, this amount has grown to astronomical proportions — many millions of dollars.This caused serious diplomatic tensions between the two countries. The situation was so difficult that Russian agencies and institutions were forced to temporarily restrict the sending of cultural exhibits and research materials to the United States due to the real risk of seizure of property on the Chabad movement's claim.🌐Compromise in Moscow and the current stateIn 2013, there was a certain turn in this issue. The russian leadership decided to transfer the identified part of the book collection from the closed state archives to the Jewish Museum and Tolerance Center in Moscow, without taking the books out of the country.The move has sparked wide public debate: whether it is a full-fledged solutionto the problem, or just an attempt to ease international judicial tensions. However, today a significant part of the historical collection is open and accessible to visitors and researchers in the Moscow museum, while discussions about its legal status and the full return of the entire library continue.source: 📖 Lubavitcher Calendar